"I wanted Mother’s Day to be a day of sentiment, not profit."
– Anna Jarvis
Mother’s Day is celebrated on May 9th 2010 in the USA, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, and other countries; it’s an occasion of flowers, gifts, visits, meals, and cards. Viewed principally as a way of honoring mothers, it’s an established annual event -- but is it still meaningful?
The American roots of Mother’s Day go back to the nineteenth century, to Anna Reeves Jarvis and her day of awareness to reduce poor health conditions in her community, for which she believed mothers to be the best advocates. Not long after, Julia Ward Howe was busy in Boston organizing a day for mothers to rally for peace, first held in 1872. After the death of Anna Reeves Jarvis in 1905, her daughter Anna M Jarvis, undertook to carry out her mother’s wish to have an official day for mothers. Tireless in her efforts, Anna even gave up her day job to find time to petition government for official adoption of the date. She succeeded and the occasion has since spread worldwide, celebrated annually in many countries. Despite the success, however, Anna herself became embittered as she watched the occasion change from one of honoring, to what she saw as being one of marketing and purchasing; apparently, she ended her days regretting her role in ever creating the day.
In learning about Anna's mixed emotions, I sensed a kindred spirit in that feeling of annoyance that a respectful observance flourished as a marketing opportunity. Even as a child I was flummoxed by the requirement for a) purchased card; b) purchased gift; and c) purchased meal out. Memories of long car trips to visit various mothers, aunts, grandmothers, and the credit card maxed out yet again, with my own mother looking frazzled on a day she was supposed to enjoy, left me feeling that the occasion seemed to lack the dignified and relaxed air it was supposedly meant to carry. But it wasn’t those visits that bothered me (well, all right, the hairy chin kisses did), it was the sense that this celebration was too commercialized.
Mothers’ Day brings out catalog craziness. One example I read had the headline: “Because mom deserves it.” Underneath this, along with the ubiquitous roses and chocolates (said roses looking suspiciously over-perfect), was a fine display of kitchenware! Kitchenware?! Mom deserves that?! I've never been able to understand just why it is OK to give a gift to a loved one that gets used by the entire household; such a gift connotes “work”, “cleaning”, “chores”! Call me antsy (and I’m willing to be enlightened on how being given a kettle, a lasagna dish, or a set of saucepans means: “Mom, I value you for the person you are”), but just how personal a gift is that?!
And should there be just one day a year when everyone else stops and says “Yay, you’re my mom?!” Of course not! How can all the amazingness, the cherishing, the good, the love that mothers are, be bundled up into one event accompanied by purchased cards, hothouse flowers, and kitchen gizmos?
Perhaps by now you're worrying that I'm pressuring for removal of the day! Hopefully I can redeem myself, for I've softened over the years. When my mother was alive, I’d call her for a chat, and despite Anna Jarvis’ swipe that cards were “a poor excuse for the letter you are too lazy to write”, I’d send one each Mother's Day, because being interstate and not exactly into writing my mother letters, it was a meaningful act for me. She enjoyed talking to me and this arrangement sufficed for both of us. It was on becoming a mother myself that I was forced to make a slight shift in perception -- children will inevitably come home from school with handmade cards and gifts, their heads and hearts filled with the importance of Mother’s Day. And what mother could possibly resist the tender-hearted, fully engaged gifting of such personally crafted love? From that first handmade effort, I realized that the meaningfulness of Mother’s Day is found in that very essence of pre-commercialized childhood, when human-to-human love is expressed through selflessness, through creation by one’s own hands of something that carries enormous love and meaning, and through the pride of giving to someone who means the whole world to you.
Today, I respect that my child believes this occasion matters and because of his belief, it does to me too. It doesn’t mean I want buy-in to the kitchen gadgets but it does mean that I'm highly appreciative that my family goes to great lengths to celebrate the occasion with me in a way that reflects what I care about. I receive hand-drawn cards, artwork from the heart, nature crafts, and if I do get purchased gifts, I'm given wonderful, considered Fair Trade treats such as soap from India, a necklace crafted in Peru, or a bar of Fair Trade chocolate. For me, it’s this thoughtfulness and honor for my beliefs about what matters that fills my heart with love on Mother’s Day.
How do you make your Mother’s Day meaningful? It’s not my place to tell you – I’d like hope you're keen to reflect on it and realize whether there are things about the way you currently celebrate it that you’d like to change. However, as guidance can be handy, here are a few ideas for both those honoring mom, and for moms who want to make the day special, to inspire your own thoughts on creating meaningfulness:
- Recognize that a shared household is a household of shared responsibilities. This means no appliances, no kitchen gadgets, no cleaning equipment ever has a place in being a personal gift on Mother’s Day. If your house needs that stuff, buy it when you need it, as a household.
- Avoid gifts that cost the Earth -- and your wallet. Instead, make something from the heart and use recycled items where possible. And make your own card! Children’s artwork is an ideal gift and can be framed with twigs, or paper borders. It's also a good idea to recycle the cards after.
- Spend time in nature together. Nature sustains us, nourishes us, and can also heal our spirit. A nature walk or hike with a picnic lunch in tow is a very affordable and connecting experience as a family. And mom gets to choose her favorite walking spot unless she’d like a surprise!
- Go Fair Trade. If you don’t fancy your handicraft skills (although it's a good time to improve them!), resort to purchasing Fair Trade items and help other moms in the process! Avoid the big and expensive – keep things simple, from the heart.
- Eat locally. If you’re going out, try to eat somewhere that sources its products locally and that has organic items on the menu. If you’re eating at home, make mom a meal that is locally sourced (your own garden, perhaps?!), organic, and filled with the love of your toil – that’s right, make a big effort!
- Talk about the concepts of honor, respect, and love. It’s a nice occasion to discuss meaningfulness and gratitude as a family. If your family is weaning off a more commercialized version of Mother’s Day, it could be the year to set the expectations for coming years.
Whatever you choose to do, make it personal. Don’t get hung up on me or anyone else telling you it’s thoughtless to buy a card or that longed-for bundt pan – if your heart is truly in it, then it is thoughtful, and it does have meaning. We create meaning through being mindful about our choices, and really, that’s the whole point of celebrating any occasion, Mother's Day included. And with that, wishing you a very meaningful Mother's Day!